Two months ago, I decided to get my own laptop for work. My Dell Latitude 110L has served me faithfully for 4 years and I've spent many fun hours working with it. It has been with me to one conference. I've written my first paper with it. I've written two more papers. And finally, I wrote my PhD thesis with it. Actually, the thesis was the one that forced me to conclude that even as I continue with the group, there's no way I can continue using that laptop. Yes, working with a 2.5 MB .ODT file with lots of images and indexes do require a fairly good computer.
My professor lent me his Macbook Pro, running Tiger. Sorry, Apple fans, but I've tried to give the OSX UI its fair chance, and it failed. And thus I decided to return the MBP and bought my own computer: a MSI Wind U123. And as I have planned, I decided to dual boot Windows XP and a flavor of Linux in it. I really had only two contenders for this: Fedora and Ubuntu, but at the end Jaunty's Netbook Remix won me over. I love Fedora and I love the idea of having cutting-edge packages, but I decided to go with a distro that uses more mature packages because I want to see how well I can work with the Ubuntu side of the netbook. As it turned out, I do approximately 95% of my work on Ubuntu, with the occasional switch to Windows side.
Two days ago, Karmic Koala (9.10) was released, and after a test using LiveUSB drive, I decided to upgrade my Jaunty installation to Karmic yesterday. I kept in mind that there are two potentially showstopping issues in MSI Winds and Karmic: errors with webcam, and flickering due to KMS. The upgrade took over 6 hours, mostly because I was trying to download from a crowded server (and with 50 KB/s download of 1.2 GB worth of files...) But the upgrade itself was smooth and issue-free, and then it's time to reboot...
Since I've disabled the webcam, the first bug was a non-issue. The second bug hit full force as Karmic loaded for the first time and my screen flickered. I'm not epileptic, but I can see it easily triggering someone's, and seizures are bad. Luckily the flicker stopped after a minute. If I try to change the brightness afterward, it tends to flicker for a while and then stabilizes. Flicker bug hits full force when I tried with a new user.
And the major issue with the upgrade? It keeps my theme from Jaunty. This is a good thing, except that the Netbook interface has been redesigned in Karmic. In Jaunty, folders and shutdown button get their own menu on the right side of the screen. In Karmic, folders are banished to its own submenu with the rest of the applications. This makes for a less cluttered desktop. The downside? The shutdown button disappears and does not reappear elsewhere. Oops. I'm a fairly veteran GNOME user at this point, so I knew how to put the shutdown button on the panel. The theme also looked awful with the new Karmic design, so I had to make a new user to copy the theme that looked good with Karmic. As it turned out, Karmic's UNR came with a default custom theme, instead of one of the defaults.
And thus, so far my first impression with Karmic Koala in my netbook is generally unfavorable. I realize that the MSI Wind isn't the most popular netbook out there, but it is reasonably common due to the various clones around the world. To have two showstopper bugs that were known by release date and yet not having a temporary fix committed for affected models in the release is... unacceptable. To have a Jaunty upgrade of Netbook Remix completely messing up the desktop also makes it unfriendly for the average user. Now, don't get me wrong. Karmic Netbook Remix looks awesome. Its design focus (to have a reasonable UI for a small screen) is great. New theme looks slick, and I love the fact that the menu is now slightly transparent so that my desktop background actually shows! Not to mention the long overdue upgrade to Firefox 3.5, and increased power efficiency (I seem to have approached 5 hours battery life under Karmic, vs. Jaunty's 4 hours). It's a worthy upgrade (although I'd have to actually use it for the next few days to see if there are other bugs that need to be worked out). Also I note that the Netbook Remix is new to Jaunty. However, given the high hopes for Karmic and Ubuntu's commitment to fix the paper cuts, I'm very disappointed. I do not consider the upgrade user-friendly. If Canonical hopes to squash Bug #1, they really need to polish up their releases instead of releasing for the sake of releasing. Otherwise they'd be Fedora without the innovation part.
I remembered that I literally spent the whole day trying many many different solutions for my Wind's Realtek RTL8187SE wireless driver problem. The driver was experimental in Jaunty and was incapable of connecting to the school network. At the end, I mucked around so much that I considered it pure luck to have it working at all, let alone connecting to school's WPA2 network. I do not know how Karmic's upgrade will affect the wireless driver, but I suspect that I'm going to have to do another day's battle with it again.
Linux is not an easy hobby...
(No, I will notupdate upgrade my Windows XP side to Windows 7. I'm a masochist but I'm not CRAZY.)
My professor lent me his Macbook Pro, running Tiger. Sorry, Apple fans, but I've tried to give the OSX UI its fair chance, and it failed. And thus I decided to return the MBP and bought my own computer: a MSI Wind U123. And as I have planned, I decided to dual boot Windows XP and a flavor of Linux in it. I really had only two contenders for this: Fedora and Ubuntu, but at the end Jaunty's Netbook Remix won me over. I love Fedora and I love the idea of having cutting-edge packages, but I decided to go with a distro that uses more mature packages because I want to see how well I can work with the Ubuntu side of the netbook. As it turned out, I do approximately 95% of my work on Ubuntu, with the occasional switch to Windows side.
Two days ago, Karmic Koala (9.10) was released, and after a test using LiveUSB drive, I decided to upgrade my Jaunty installation to Karmic yesterday. I kept in mind that there are two potentially showstopping issues in MSI Winds and Karmic: errors with webcam, and flickering due to KMS. The upgrade took over 6 hours, mostly because I was trying to download from a crowded server (and with 50 KB/s download of 1.2 GB worth of files...) But the upgrade itself was smooth and issue-free, and then it's time to reboot...
Since I've disabled the webcam, the first bug was a non-issue. The second bug hit full force as Karmic loaded for the first time and my screen flickered. I'm not epileptic, but I can see it easily triggering someone's, and seizures are bad. Luckily the flicker stopped after a minute. If I try to change the brightness afterward, it tends to flicker for a while and then stabilizes. Flicker bug hits full force when I tried with a new user.
And the major issue with the upgrade? It keeps my theme from Jaunty. This is a good thing, except that the Netbook interface has been redesigned in Karmic. In Jaunty, folders and shutdown button get their own menu on the right side of the screen. In Karmic, folders are banished to its own submenu with the rest of the applications. This makes for a less cluttered desktop. The downside? The shutdown button disappears and does not reappear elsewhere. Oops. I'm a fairly veteran GNOME user at this point, so I knew how to put the shutdown button on the panel. The theme also looked awful with the new Karmic design, so I had to make a new user to copy the theme that looked good with Karmic. As it turned out, Karmic's UNR came with a default custom theme, instead of one of the defaults.
And thus, so far my first impression with Karmic Koala in my netbook is generally unfavorable. I realize that the MSI Wind isn't the most popular netbook out there, but it is reasonably common due to the various clones around the world. To have two showstopper bugs that were known by release date and yet not having a temporary fix committed for affected models in the release is... unacceptable. To have a Jaunty upgrade of Netbook Remix completely messing up the desktop also makes it unfriendly for the average user. Now, don't get me wrong. Karmic Netbook Remix looks awesome. Its design focus (to have a reasonable UI for a small screen) is great. New theme looks slick, and I love the fact that the menu is now slightly transparent so that my desktop background actually shows! Not to mention the long overdue upgrade to Firefox 3.5, and increased power efficiency (I seem to have approached 5 hours battery life under Karmic, vs. Jaunty's 4 hours). It's a worthy upgrade (although I'd have to actually use it for the next few days to see if there are other bugs that need to be worked out). Also I note that the Netbook Remix is new to Jaunty. However, given the high hopes for Karmic and Ubuntu's commitment to fix the paper cuts, I'm very disappointed. I do not consider the upgrade user-friendly. If Canonical hopes to squash Bug #1, they really need to polish up their releases instead of releasing for the sake of releasing. Otherwise they'd be Fedora without the innovation part.
I remembered that I literally spent the whole day trying many many different solutions for my Wind's Realtek RTL8187SE wireless driver problem. The driver was experimental in Jaunty and was incapable of connecting to the school network. At the end, I mucked around so much that I considered it pure luck to have it working at all, let alone connecting to school's WPA2 network. I do not know how Karmic's upgrade will affect the wireless driver, but I suspect that I'm going to have to do another day's battle with it again.
Linux is not an easy hobby...
(No, I will not
Leave a comment

